Hi,
I just started playing with JRuby. This is my first ruby post. I had a hard time understanding classes vs objects in Ruby. It doesnt mean like what classes & objects in other Object oriented laguages. for an example
Class.is_a? Object
returns true
and
Object.is_a? Object
too.
so class & Object are both objects
here comes another one
Class.is_a? Class
returns true
and
Object.is_a? Class
too.
wait, i am not done yet
Object.instance_of? Class
Class.instance_of? Class
Both are true
Object.instance_of? Object
Class.instance_of? Object
Both are false. right, nothing can be instance of object.
And
Class.kind_of? Class
Object.kind_of? Class
both are true
Class.kind_of? Object
Object.kind_of? Object
both are true
So both are exactly same, then why do we have both these.?
After some more digging, i wrote this simple method to return method list supported by both
irb(main):054:0> def print_methods(obj)
irb(main):055:1> obj.methods.each do |mm|
irb(main):056:2* puts mm
irb(main):057:2> end
irb(main):058:1> end
Only method difference between print_methods(Object) and print_methods(Class) is
Nesting
if Nesting means inheritance, Is Object similar to the sealed class??
Can someone clarify me what is all this?
Update: To Edds comment
Interestingly i see lot of differences in the method list in
c=Class.new
print_methods(c)
&
o=Object.new
print_methods(o)
Now I understand Instance of a class is really an class instance (And this class instance is actually a Object) not an object instance. And even this instance allow me to span another instances
xx = c.new //works - c is an Object / and xx is a instance of an Object c
yy = o.new //nope - o is already a instance of an Object, so it cannot be instantiated again
So Finally, Object is really an instance of a Class. Because
xx.is_a? Class
is false, but
xx.is_a? Object
returns true
Am i right, ??
Cheers
(This question has been successfully answered already, but since this is an important topic, another answer can't hurt)
Basically the key thing to understand is that every class is an instance of the Class class and every class (in 1.8) is a subclass of Object. So every class is an object in the sense that it is an instance of a subclass of Object, i.e. Class.
Of course this means that Class is an instance of itself. If that makes your brain hurt, just don't think about it too deeply.
Object and Class are is_a? Object
x.is_a? y returns true if x.class == y or x.class < y, i.e. if x's class is y or x's class inherits from y. Since every class inherits from object x.is_a? Object returns true no matter what x is. (In 1.8 anyway, in 1.9 there's also BasicObject which is now the most basic class in the inheritance hierarchy).
They are also is_a? Class
Both Object and Class are indeed classes, so that should not be surprising.
They are also instance_of? Class, but not instance_of? Object.
Unlike is_a?, x.instance_of? y only returns true if x.class == y, not if x.class is a subclass of y. So since both x and y are instance_of? Class, they're not instance_of? Object.
right, nothing can be instance of object.
That's not true. Object.new.instance_of? Object is true.
kind_of?
kind_of? is an alias for is_a?, so see above.
So both are exactly same, then why do we have both these.?
It should be pointed out that everything up to now is true for all classes. E.g. String.is_a? Object, String.is_a? Class and String.instance_of? Class are true and String.instance_of? Object is false for the same reasons as above. (Also String.is_a? String and String.instance_of? String are both false for the same reasons - String is a class, not a string).
You can not conclude from that all the classes are the same. They're just all instances of the same class.
Comparing methods
Since both Object and Class are classes, they both have all the instance methods defined by Class. Class additionally has the singleton method nesting. nesting tells you which module you're currently nested in, it has nothing to do with inheritance.
For any given class TheClass.methods will return the instance methods defined by Class (e.g. superclass which returns the class which TheClass inherits from, and new which creates a new instance of TheClass) plus the singleton methods defined by that class.
Anyway method only tells you which methods can be called directly on a given object. It does not tell you which methods can be called on an instance of a class. For that you can use instance_methods which returns significantly different results for Object and Class.